October 16th, 2004

So the highly anticipated (well, among her fans, anyway) North American debut album of Japan’s Hikaru Utada is here…. and so’s my review. Like the devoted fan I am, I got it today, on its -er- ninth day of release. :biggrin:

I got my grubby little hands on a copy of UTADA’s Exodus Thursday. That was satisfying. I called several music stores, only to be told that “we don’t have any copies in stock, sorry… you might try phoning our other branches.” Oh well. I double checked the store I’d visited last week, and they had plenty in stock. Unfortunately, they were all at a listening post, which I didn’t see until I was about to ask an employee for help. Heh. I haven’t listened to it all the way through yet. Some of the songs are good, a few make me cringe, and others just aren’t memorable at all.

01 – “Opening”
“I don’t wanna crossover / Between this genre, that genre”
Suits its purpose, I suppose. Practically an instrumental.

02 – “Devil Inside”
“Maybe there’s a devil somewhere really deep inside of me”
Yeah, I downloaded this track beforehand. Shhh. A very good dance/club track. The track sounds a bit overproduced at times, but Utada’s decided to add some traditional Asian instruments (I couldn’t tell you what they are, but it’s distinctly an Asian sound) to the heavy techno-synth she has going on.

03 – “Exodus ’04”
“Through traffic jams in Tokyo / new music on the radio”
I think this song is the one that’s most similar to her Japanese releases. I suppose one could say it’s a gestalt–the sum is greater than the parts. While the lyrics are better than some of the other offerings on this disc, they too fall into the trap of being repetitive; and the backing on its own isn’t extraordinary. However, these elements combine to form a track that’s really easy on the ears.

04 – “The Workout”
“Ain’t it good to be alive tonight”
The song that isn’t about a workout at all >>;; Maybe it’s just me, but I feel that she’s singing just a tad out of her range here… so it’s not really one of my favourites. It’s got an infectious beat, though.

05 – “Easy Breezy”
“You’re Easy Breezy and I’m Japaneesy”
Right, and the lyrics are cheesy. Also, a little tongue-in-cheek reversal here. Instead of random English in Japanese pop songs, now we’re treated to random Japanese in English pop songs! Heh. Pure pop, in a carefree insouciant summer kinda way. Actually, the entire song is tongue-in-cheek. At least that’s the feeling I get after listening to it countless times…

06 – “Tippy Toe”
“Problems kept inside, look neat and organized / what you need in life is some wonder”
This is a song I hate to love. I will say one thing: the girl knows how to write catchy.

07 – “Hotel Lobby”
“This is not what she expected / her hopes, they stretch and they bend”
Is this a song about… prostitution?! Some eclectic pseudo-Carribbean-type beats here, which actually work quite well in the song, although there seems to be this awkward juxtaposition between the melody and the lyrics.

08 – “Animato”
“Somebody out there better get this”
That person isn’t me, then. Actually, I don’t really mind this song at all. It sounds like this is Utada singing about her own album.

09 – “Crossover Interlude”
“Together you and I–we can / Cross all borders, you and I”
An interesting little interlude (a play within a play?) with the same lyrics as the first track.

10 – “Kremlin Dusk”
“I run a secret propaganda / aren’t we all hiding pieces of broken anger”
I like it, with the exception of the “ooOooOooOooooOOOOO” parts (you really need to listen to it to understand what I mean.) It seems to change into a completely different song about halfway through–the beginning gives the impression that the song is a angsty ballad. Well, I guess it is angsty, but it is by no means a ballad–it’s a rock song that retains just enough of the melody to maintain coherence.

11 – “You Make Me Want to Be a Man”
“Arguments that have no meaning / this is just the way I am”
Right, so who among you out there didn’t see the title and do a double take? Okay, so the song actually makes some sense–it’s about the great possibility for miscommunication between the sexes, so… right.

12 – “Wonder ‘Bout”
“How many nights did I wander in the dark / counting secrets of my heart”
Incredibly repetitive. It just loops over and over again, or at least it sounds like it does.

13 – “Let Me Give You My Love”
“I was sort of like soul-searching”
Was she really? Because if she was, I’m not terribly impressed. This, out of all the tracks, sounds the most like a random North American song played on a Top 40 radio station. Again, though, I’m pressed to admit that this song will probably be stuck in my head for a while–it’s probably just the beats and her phrasing.

14 – “About Me”
“Is it okay if I’m not cute and naive”
At first, this song has an acoustic guitar, which is a really nice change from all the electronica in… all of the other songs, but alas, it’s not going to stay this way.

So, overall… I have a feeling this is a bit of an experiment for Utada; with such a large fanbase in Japan, a flop here wouldn’t kill her career. I wish she wouldn’t play on her Asian heritage so much, though. It’s rather like playing the race card. Hrm. Taken as a whole, this album isn’t her best work. I guess I’d give it a B.

This entry was posted on Saturday, October 16th, 2004 at 10:42 am and is filed under general. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

2 Responses to “Exodus review”

Megan Says:

Thanks for the great review, Cat!! I’m thinking about buying it…do you suggest dishing out the money for it? What is your favorite Japanese album of hers?
~Megan

Cat Says:

Megan, I’m glad you liked the review! As a fan, I pretty much had to get it; I think it depends on how much of a fan you are. I don’t think I would have liked it as much if I weren’t already a fan. I’d still like “Exodus ’04” and “Hotel Lobby” regardless; but some of the others are on shaky ground. Anyway. I’d suggest getting it, as long as you keep an open mind and don’t pick it up with the expectation that it will sound like her Japanese releases (a little ironic given the thank you message in the liner notes…) And I’m afraid I wouldn’t be able to tell you which of her Japanese albums I like best, given that I have only a spotty collection of mp3s… In terms of individual songs, though, my top three are probably “Sakura Drops,” “Uso mitai na I Love You,” and “Addicted to You.” Oh, and “First Love” just because :dorkygrin: